: Holly Goldberg Sloan
Age Range: Middle School Age 8-12
Release: January, 31 2017
Rating: 3 out of 5
DISCLAIMER: I received an advance copy of Short from the publisher through NetGalley for the purposes of writing a review.
Publisher’s Description: Julia is very short for her age, but by the end of the summer run of The Wizard of Oz, she’ll realize how big she is inside, where it counts. She hasn’t ever thought of herself as a performer, but when the wonderful director of Oz casts her as a Munchkin, she begins to see herself in a new way. Julia becomes friendly with the poised and wise Olive–one of the adults with dwarfism who’ve joined the production’s motley crew of Munchkins. With her deeply artistic neighbor, Mrs. Chang, Julia’s own sense of self as an artist grows. Soon, she doesn’t want to fade into the background–and it’s a good thing, because her director has more big plans for Julia!
The major concern I had for the book was how the beginning of the book was all over the place. The book starts off telling us the time when Julia heard her parents talking about how tall she is and then moves on to Ramon, her dog (which I had trouble following). Then tells us about her Uncle Jake and Aunt Megan and how Uncle Jake likes to carve. And that is just Chapter One.
The book, for me didn’t catch my interest until the author talked about the play and the lack of interest Julia had until she met Olive, Quincy, and Larry. Then I wanted to read more. I felt that most of Chapter One and Two could have been done in flash backs or discussion Julia has.
Until I read the whole book, I can’t give a true review. There was enough there to keep me interested and want to see where Holly Goldberg Sloan takes her characters. Will update when I can read whole book.
: Trolls Writer: Dave Scheidt; Bergens Writer: Tini Howard
Artist and Colorist: Kathryn Hudson
Age Range: 6-10
Release: September 2016
Rating: 2 out of 5
Description from Publisher:
It’s the Trolls first graphic novel! Who are the Trolls? Who are the Bergens? Why is there one Troll who isn’t happy like all the other Trolls? And why does this Troll know more about the Bergens than any other Troll? Find out more about Poppy and Branch in this all-new collection of comics that take place before the Trolls motion picture. Warning: You may never look at a cupcake the same way after you see this graphic novel.
DISCLAIMER: I received an advance copy of Trolls #1: Hugs and Friends from the publisher through NetGalley for the purposes of writing a review.
My kids and I wanted to like this book, but something was lost. If you haven’t seen the movie Trolls and don’t know the characters, this graphic novel doesn’t help to introduce the them and what they are about. There are fifteen short stories in the book with 55 actual story pages. This gives you an average of three pages per story. Not a lot time to create a story and get into it.
My daughter, who reads a lot of graphic novels, finished this in one setting. She told me that the stories were uninteresting and the characters were forgettable. She usually reads books many times, but I have yet to see her read this one twice. She (and I) went into this book hoping to meet the characters (especially since this is the first book and we haven’t seen the movie) and find out who they are. It feels like the authors assumed that everyone reading the book has seen the movie.
I really like the illustrations by Kathryn Hudson. They made the characters more enjoyable. The only problem was that the stories didn’t keep me or my daughter engaged.